Portage Pie

Great pies! Just bought their strawberry pie. It's pretty good! Freshly made. Just come prepared. It's cash or check only and if your looking for something specific then call and order ahead. It's literally a tiny hallway to pick up pie orders. They have some already made but selection is limited. Still totally worth it! I was not local and just sorta stopped in. Glad I did!

We've never had any complaints with Portage all the times that we have come and or put orders in a head of time. We ordered a specific pie today. Got it home and cut it to eat and it was so tart that it physically made tongues hurt from the tartness of the berries. We added sugar to the top of the pie just to cut the tartness but every time we've ordered this pie we have never had this problem. We're not unhappy with the service and or the bake of the pie. Just not up to par this go around and very hard to eat which makes us not feel that it was worth our money that we spent on it.

The best pies I've ever had! Dessert is an important food group for me, and Chautauqua has no shortage of it. From Perry's ice cream to Amish baked goods, there is plenty to eat up. The pies I've had at various restaurants and farm stands have been good too, but none have compared to Portage Pie! Our family has been getting them for years and we look forward to picking them up each annual vacation. Over the years we've tried a variety of flavors: dutch apple, cherry, coconut, etc. My personal favorite, however, has always been chocolate. It was a wonderful flavor that other french silk or chocolate pudding pies lack. The crust is thin an flaky, never wet or mushy. And the whipped cream topping is a thick layer and homemade, definitely not from a can of Reddi Whip. I miss the smaller pies I remember buying, but knowing how fast our family inhales this delicious pie that would never suffice now. The shop has a delightful and bright exterior just a few storefronts down from the center of Westfield. I love visiting this picturesque town for the farmers market, architecture, and proximity to Lake Erie, so picking up pies is usually on our way. Due to their popularity you are best to order ahead of time, especially for the more popular flavors like chocolate. We've showed up last year and had to wait in a hot line outside due to the covid policy they had in place, but it was worth it. They also are pricier than most pies and went up again this past year, perhaps due to inflation or supply chain issues like many other businesses suffered from. Considering the quality and it being an annual splurge on our summer vacation, we find it worth it! Everyone should treat themselves to their favorite flavor from this wonderful shop, even if its just once.

This is how much pie we have left after we got it today. I’m thinking we’re doing pretty good so far. Well what can I say about this place. It absolutely amazing. We snuck it at closing time today and got the last pie available. Banana cream. Just add that one to the list of awesome pies at this place. You CANNOT go wrong with whatever delicious pie you choose. Just hope they have one available or even call ahead and reserve one.