Old Bay Cafe

What took me so long to come here?! I just moved from Southern Maryland and it's awesome I can have that style of seafood in Florida! One of the best crab cake I've ever had! Need to come back and try the rest of the menu! Cream of Crab Bisque was flavorful and had lumps of crab it, but a little heads up, it's thick like Greek yogurt. Not a bad thing, just don't expect a normal Bisque.

Been driving by for years always saying we wanted to go in. Today we finally did and it was amazing food. I had the crab cake sandwich and my wife had the fish tacos. Great flavor and No Fill in the cakes. The servers were very nice and smiling which always make it a nice experience .We go to too many places where they seem to be inconvenienced by you being in their restaurant/store. This will definitely be on our list of regular stops!!

Our neighbor wanted us to try your crab cakes and treated us to sandwiches as a to go order. on the 28th of April. Picture says it all, burnt, burnt,burnt chips and crab cake. I can’t believe you let the chef plate a to go order like this. Management should be ashamed of themselves. Hundreds may see this review, is it worth it? to send out food cooked like this? After the first bite containing shells (yuk) amongst other bites with shells the inside was was very tasty after I cut away the burnt outer. You are Advertising low filler I experienced a lot of binder isn’t that the same thing?

Highly disappointed. I'm from Maryland, born and raised. Drove over 3 hours from where we live now in Florida to this place. I saw a post on Facebook from Locash saying it was authentic MD cakes. Nothing authentic about the crabcakes. Over fried ball of bread with very little meat. The website says "backfin and claw meat" in the cakes. Not true. The crab bisque is more like a can of thick condensed soup with no crab meat and a sprinkle of old bay. It was cold and gross. Should have know from the prices nothing was authentic. Unless you think seeing a fried ball with little strings of what might be crab throughout filler is what you want. I tasted it, told the girl, and gave it back to her. I didn't eat it.

I enjoy the people here as well as their food. I would consider this place one of my top hidden gems. First time I went here I had their Crabcake Patty Melt with Mac and Cheese Balls as an appetizer. Then I literally craved it for the next couple weeks until I returned with my girlfriend and yet again with my cousin. Every time I tell myself I'll try and save some but end up devouring all of my yummy food. I also personally like the feel of the environment which makes me feel as though I'm escaping the general New Port Richey essence. Great place to check out if you haven't. One of my absolute favorite places in this area! I'm just sorry that my photos do not do the food justice.