Fresh Pie

Decent little hole in the wall pizzeria. We ordered a pretty big order. For a start our Calzones were FANTASTIC 10/10 ! The pizza looked and tasted great but the middle center of the pizza around 50% of the pizza was extremely thin and would fall apart when you picked it up. The wings were pretty good, they are baked and I have to admit they are very large wings compared to other restaurants that offer them as well as super juicy. We ordered mild and lemon pepper. To be honest we couldn't tell them apart almost. The lemon pepper is not strong nor does it have a lot of seasoning. The mild almost tastes as if it has no sauce on them. Only other downside is once they cook and are plated the wings sit in a pool of their own grease (the foil they cook in gets put right into the styrofoam plate) and they end up being really greasy. We only live 5 mins away and our wings were soggy with grease by the time we got home to eat. The breadsticks were undercooked and gummy... Don't get me wrong, it's not a bad place to eat... but for 2 LG calzones, 1 LG pizza, 40 wings, breadsticks and cheesy bread at $110 spent we should have had near perfect food especially at that price range...

Talk about a hidden gem! Beats every place around here if you're from the north and like a good pie! Two thumbs up give more if I had them🤣. We had the white pizza (true white pizza) with sun dried tomatoes, sausage and spinach WOW! And garlic parmesan wings perfection (only compliant could be fried a bit longer)~ master chef dee

Highly recommend: Just passing through and staying at a hotel. Decided to grab some pizza for dinner. We got two large pizzas, bread sticks, 3 garlic sauce cups, tomato sauce cup and delivery all for just $33. It was some of the best pizza I've ever ordered. We got the white pizza and a cheese pizza for the kids. And we got the regular bread sticks. I would definitely go for this place over dominos or papa johns. Only took about 30 minutes to get the food and it was hot and delicious. After a very long drive from Indiana we were thrilled to get a hot and delicious pizza!

This is great pizza with quality ingredients at a fair price. If u like mom and pop style pizza that's hand tossed with thick chewy crust then this is the place to go. At first i was skeptical as so many people in the area leave great reviews for other pizza establishments and i go there and its no where near as good as quality as they are raving about. But this pizza place surpassed my expectations in every way.

The pizza here is FANTASTIC!!! By far the best in town.... but what good is being the best IF YOU NEVER ANSWER THE DANG PHONE!!!!!! I really hate to pile it on here, but the last 3 times ive been frustrated enough from the not answering the phone that i literally drove up there to place my carry out order and wait 30 mins in theparking lot, there have been handwritten notes on the door saying they were not opening at all or opening later. I hope they get it together because the pizza really is quite good.

We spent all day at the Raceway in Reynolds and got to our room hungry. We found this place online and the wife called to see if they delivered to our motel. The person on the phone was very helpful and courteous. We called back and ordered the Ultimate Car Tire pie, 😲per their menu. The pizza arrived and girl was also very polite and courteous. We opened the pizza and Omg 😳, it was just as advertised, Big as a Tire. It was AWESOME. We called the store to give them the appreciation they deserved. I did notice that this is a family business, not a chain store. We will definitely be enjoying this place everytime we are in the area. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND you give this place s shot when you can. Thanks you all for a Great Experience ❤️