Brooklyn Pizza

Great pizza and wings!! A little pricey but guaranteed to be the best around Erie in my opinion and some of the largest portions around too. If you normally get a large at other places, you'll need no more than a medium here. Count on your food being delivered about 5-10 minutes earlier than what they tell you. Very fast!!!!

Excellent pizza. Huge 18" thin crust NY style pies. The white pizza is perfect. The red is great but on the sweet side. Wood fire effects are very subtle. The specialty topping combinations are well chosen. But whatever the toppings, the star of the Brooklyn show is the crust. Erie is something of a pizza dessert - some joints still use pre made crusts!? - but the crust is the pizza and Brooklyn gets that. Great that there are two locations - south and west suburbs - hoping for one in central city.

These guys do an awesome job. Lots of options, the ingredients are great and the place is clean. Everyone was friendly when I went in to pick up. The slices are huge, even on the medium. But the crust isn't bready like some places. You actually get what you pay for. I strongly recommend their jalapeno popper pizza. It's amazing.

Erie is a difficult city to get good pizza in. Brooklyn's pizza and wings are both excellent, but a little on the pricey side. A few times when they were busy they have given us the wrong sauce on our wings or the wrong pizza which considering the price was too much to botch, so check your order before you leave.

Just ordered tonight and had a horrible experience. I ordered cheese sticks not cheesy garlic bread, a medium chicken ranch pizza that was completely DRY, and 2 pep balls, nothing to write home about at all. When i arrived 10 minutes later than THEY told me, my pizza was done but was told my pep balls were over cooked so they did make me 4 more for free which was nice. When i finally got my whole order is when i noticed they gave me garlic cheese bread when i ordered cheese sticks? I told them that wasn't what i ordered and they were willing to make me some cheese sticks but because i had already waited an extra 5-7 minutes and i had to pick up my children i said it was fine and left. Staff was very nice but the food is not good at all. Would not recommend or go back.

Honestly I have NEVER even been able to experience Brooklyn Pizza and that's an absolute shame. I have tried for almost 2 years now (hearing how good they are) and haven't had any kind of contact that's an absolute issue. I have let it ring numerous times on numerous occasions throughout the last 2 years and absolutely NOTHING. I NEVER leave bad reviews however it is an issue when you are open and there is no communication on more than several occasions