Circle Pizza

The BEST pizza you will EVER have. We have been visiting circle pizza for over 20 years. We visit every summer when we are vacationing in Avalon, NJ. We wish having their pizza wasn’t just limited to our summer vacations. Also, their cheesesteak eggrolls with the spicy ketchup is 10/10. We look forward to this pizza EVERY year!!! we love circle so much!! 🍕

After our usual go-to pizza place closed down, we tried circle pizza and we were very impressed with the pizza takeout. We are a picky family when it comes to pizza so the bar was high. If you are after a pizza night, then look no further! The sausage pizza was particularly good. They also do a decent gluten free pie as we have someone in our family who has a gluten sensitivity.

Circle Pizza has a solid pizza for not coming out of North Jersey. (IYKYK) Walked over from Avalon beach & took 10 mins to walk each way. I would recommend this as a quick bite for lunch. Disappointed though my pies were sitting for 15 minutes after I paid before they realized they were mine. Pizza was room temp by the time I got back to my party. Also, this place was cash only - which is fine - but have the change in your drawer to be exclusively cash. Ended up telling the woman at the register not to worry about the change & put it in tip jar- but she was told to just keep the nickles in the drawer instead. A tip is a tip. A tip is not meant to be kept in the drawer for the establishment.

I'm harsh on pizza and this was better than good. We got 2 small pies, well done, cheese and pepperoni. A tiny bit of grease but a great sign of good pizza is that the grease doesn't just run off the pizza like an oily leak. All ingredients of pizza stayed put and the crust had good crisp. Fresh salad, too! To add to the experience, they have a great outdoor dining area that had live music. Ample space for kids to run around and ple ty of outdoor seating. After a number of up and down years, it appears current ownership/management has this figured out. I'm going back for a t shirt!

A must stop when visiting Cape May County. Circle Pizza offers a thin crust pie that is tasty. Normally would give it five star, but giving it 4 for the following reasons. While I realize this place is in Avalon, for a 16 inch pie, the price of $21.95 is a bit pricey. While on vacation? I don't mind digging deep, but I would not pay these prices on a regular basis. Also, a sign is posted on menu board that prices are subject to change without notice. While the posted price was $21.95, a large pie was $22.89. The garlic bread that was $6.99 was $7.99 and a small 2 ounce sauce cup w as $1.15. While I understand the need to increase prices, take the time to change the menus. When I ordered my pie over the phone for pickup, when we arrived, I decided to eat it there being there was nobody sitting in dinning area. I arrived early and requested the pizza be served on a tray being we were going to eat in. After waiting a while, I looked at the to go boxes and noticed the pizza was sitting in a pizza coffin (pizza box). Not sure how long it was sitting , but as we all know, a pie fresh from the oven is much different than one that changes in a box. Yes, I know I ordered takeout and changed my mind, but how hard is it to put it on a tray. All in all, I will it was a great pizza and I'm sure I'll always stop in. I've never had anything but the pizza so I can't really comment.