Chicago Pizza

Oh my God this place must be money laundering with food as a front. I ordered a pizza and lasagna for $70! Prices weren’t listed nor mentioned and I didn’t ask because who would think 1 pizza would cost $45. The pizza sucked and the dough was definitely a pre made from Safeway. And the lasagna was like a tomato soup with pepperonis in it. Pepperonis! So nasty. I threw it all away. Have you ever seen pepperonis in a lasagna. Anyway. Don’t go here. Go to Alpine pizza in lionshead. The pizza is incredible and the dough is inspired. Zero stars would be appropriate here. The delivery driver was very cordial and was easily the best part of my meal.

Don't waste your time here. Called an hour before closing for delivery and somehow it was my fault they didn't currently have a delivery driver. The woman who answered the phone would only take an order if I could arrive to pick it up 15 minutes later (45 minutes prior to closing). I agreed and started placing my order, but halfway through this woman starts cutting me off, taking issue with regular menu items in the order, laughing in my face...it was astonishing how rude this person was, but having read the other reviews, it seems clear she's the owner and this is a pretty regular occurrence.

This place was recommend by one of our shuttle drivers so we opted to try them out. We were very disappointed. We ordered the 18" with pepperoni, Italian sausage, and half jalapeño. The pizza looked great but as soon as I took a bite I was disappointed. The crust is terrible. It looked like a saltine cracker in texture, the dough is not fluffy, or soft. When you tear into the crust, you can see the layers like a flat bread, but bland. We would have been better off ordering Dominos Pizza and gotten three large pizzas with three toppings for the same price. The irony is that they had a sign at their counter that said "Friends don't let friends order Dominos". Well, maybe they should.

Only reason I'm giving this restaurant two stars instead of one is because the lady who took our order was really nice. Pizza was definitely not worth the price. I feel like frozen pizza at the supermarket would have been a better buy/value then what we got here. Got the supreme pizza. Barely had any toppings on it. Supreme might have a different meaning out here. Definitely disappointed as this was our first meal in Vail.