Jimmy's New York Pizzeria

My first time eat Jimmy's, I did carry out. I'm very impressed with the customer service and the quality of the pizza. The location is not easily seen from the street, but it worth finding. I highly recommend finding Jimmy's New York Pizzeria! Update: It was so good yesterday that I had to go back with my family. We now have a new favorite place for pizza! Sorry Marino's of Jacksonville, North Carolina, you have been replaced. (2) We've eaten at Jimmy's many times and Love it! Today we heard of a possible menu addition of a "Jawbreaker", I can't wait! And a B.A. location?

I am a New Yorker and Jimmy's Pizza was good. I had a greek salad - 1 very large slice of Pizza and a cannoli. The Cannoli made me want to weep. It was just like home!! Delicious - I was so full and still ate the whole thing. The staff was super friendly and quick. Cute little place. You should try it if you are in the Tulsa area.

This place is just fantastic, you could really feel the New York "family" vibe in there with the staff. This coming from a guy who has never stepped foot in NY lol. The slice was huge. The sauce was awesome, the staton island white with its ricotta was amazing! That cannoli? fuhgeddaboudit!!! Lol, that is some legit cannoli! Also, Jimmy was super nice. Sitting there doing financials on off time cracking jokes and having fun. Good place! (Update)- went again, love it even more! This kid walked in, arms open wide and declared *in best Italian big man voice impersonation possible* "EEEYYYY JJJIIIIMMMAAAAYYYY"..... Jimmy replied in kind....LOVE the vibe of this place!

My husband discovered Jimmy's just by chance on Google. It is not super close to our house, but he still wanted to give it a shot. We did a to go order. Our order ended up being ready before the time they had quoted! Walking into Jimmy's I was greeted like I was family. The lady that helped me, I believe was one of the owners. She was amazingly kind. It smelled delicious, and there were several tables where you could tell they were regulars based on their interactions with the staff. Once I paid and was leaving, every single person working said goodbye and thank you. We will definitely be going back based on the customer service and how amazing our pizza tasted! I believe we had the Staten Island White pizza.