Sara's Sweets

The cupcakes and cake for my granddaughters first birthday were perfect! The cake was a bit too dense to be used as a smash cake so we just let her tear it apart. Beautifully decorated and it fit the birthday theme "Wild One" perfectly!! This is my go to place for birthdays and will continue to be in the future. We were new to the banana cream flavor but it was amazing. My granddaughter proudly ate and wore it in her hair and tutu. They also have a great variety of treats to avoid a lot of allergies. Best gluten free cookies I've had!

My wife rarely says if she truly likes something. If I ask, she usually responds with “ it’s ok” or “it’s alright”. We recently purchased some of Sara’s chocolate covered strawberries. As soon as my wife tried one she turned to me and said “that’s good”. I was shocked. All I know is if my wife says they’re good they must actually be amazing.

I placed a large order online for cookies for my office, expecting them to just be shipped the following Monday. We’re a good 45 minutes away from Lima. Sara called me shortly after and asked if she could deliver the cookies, and which day and time would be best. She also offered me a wider selection than I was able to select online, so I was able to get some St. Patty’s day cookies as well as another flavor that I requested. She drove all this way to hand deliver them and they were of course AMAZING. Can’t recommend this place enough! I plan on ordering again in the future, hopefully for our whole company next time. Thank you!!!

The place smells amazing (and its attached to a coffee shop). Purchased a dozen cupcakes (buckeye, black bottom cheesecake,confetti, OH, monster, brownie bash). On same day, the cake was super fresh goodness however, they quickly became stale after day 1. The frosting looked beautiful though it was quite gritty....so much I couldn't finish it.