Brooklyn Pie Co

If you’re in the area, this is a great eatery to visit. We normally like a thin crust pizza. This wasn’t too bad. Pleasant staff and nice shop. They were out of mushrooms. How does a pizza parlor run out of mushrooms in the middle of the day? lol… never the less, we enjoyed the pie and the cold beer. We would go back do you should give it a try.

We had a delivery order. It took almost an hour so order promptly. But the single pizza price is huge! The wings were ok. I wish I had gotten a spicy sauce or Tabasco with my order, I did not get celery with my order so the menu may need updating. The chocolate cake was large but kind of dry. Get the cheesecake!

This local pizza place is a true standout. The exceptional customer service, including offering a military discount without prompting, is a testament to their commitment to the community. It's the best pizza on the island, hands down. The crust is perfectly crispy, and the toppings are fresh. But what truly sets them apart is their remarkable staff. They make you feel like a regular, whether it's your first visit or hundredth. Their warmth and dedication to ensuring your dining experience is stellar is outstanding. It's safe to say this place is a slice of pizza paradise with unbeatable service, military support, great prices, and the island's finest pizza. Don't miss it!

Great pizza however it was the service that will bring me back. They were very busy (I’m guessing that’s the usual activity for this establishment) and McKayla was AWESOME!!! She was getting things done, multitasking over load and keeping everything running smoothly. All with a beautiful smile and professionalism that is hard to find these days, with an “I’ve got this under control” can do attitude of just “get it done”. I’ll be back for sure next beach trip around.

First time eating here. The service was prompt and polite, dining area was clean and the pizza was decent. For me personally, the main portion of crust...under toppings...was very thin and very wet making it where you couldn't do a traditional pizza fold to eat it so you needed to use a fork to eat your pizza. The upside to the pizza, I got the Supreme NY, was the toppings were plentiful and great tasting.

The pizza tastes very good. Probably one of the top 3 pizzas I've eaten here in Texas. Not skimpy on toppings. Would definitely go back. Only reason I give 4 and not 5 is because the girl that answers phone and is also cashier is on the rude side. She can definitely benefit from customer service classes. We want Brooklyn style pizza without the Brooklyn style attitude 😂

This had to have been the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. Seriously! The meat, cheese, and veggies were all fresh, the crust was exquisitely crisp with a soft center, and it was served piping hot. The gentlemen who runs the place is legit, and was very kind to me and my kids, even when they were fussy. He was even kind enough to cut their pizza up into kid-sized pieces. Dining-in is basic, as the place has been there a while, so don’t expect booster chairs if you have toddlers, but hey, that’s part of the charm, as this is what I experienced as a kid, and it was clean. Will definitely be patronizing again!