Sinapi's Pizzeria

Every time I get back into NY to visit my parents I stop at Sinapi's Pizzeria & Restaurant.. I will stop before I get to my parents and pick up a pie or slices. Even if I am on my way to eat a meal. All of Sinapi's food is wonderful but for me their pizza is just about a perfect NY slice. I can't wait to get back there and grab a pie. I love all their toppings but there is something special about their Mushroom pies.

I will never order from here again. Normally Mezza Luna is our go to but, we decided to go with a little change - what a mistake. We called at 707p and ordered just a large pie with sausage and pepperoni. Such a simple order. We called at 845pm because no one delivered the pie. This pizzeria is only at most 12 mins from my home. When my husband called the woman that answered the phone asked him "did they leave it at the front door?" I was so disgusted with that comment. Why in the world would someone leave our pizza on the stairs and not knock was my question. We got a call a few minutes later from a young lady who was scared about coming down our development driveway. I cannot blame her honestly. Its now 9pm and we finally got our COLD pizza. It was so cold it may as well have sat outside in the snow. They need to do better and it very clear that customer service is NOT their strong point. We will be going back to Mezza Luna. Their food and service is extraordinary.

Sinapis pizza in Brewster is delicious. The food we had was outstanding. We had a number of dishes from appetizer to pizza to Italian specialties and every one of them was scrumptious! The service was fast, and friendly and a real pleasure. If you are looking for delicious Italian fare, in a family friendly atmosphere, look no further than Sinapis Pizzeria in Brewster.