Antonio’s

We were informed by the hostess upon arrival that they no longer serve Italian food or pizza at Antonio's Pizzeria. This was disappointing since we were going there to try the pizza and pizzeria is right there in the name. We decided to give them a try anyways since we were there and had a food credit from our hotel. We were seated outside by the water with an incredible view. It was around 6 pm so there was shade and a nice breeze. While they don't have pizza anymore, they do have Flatbreads (BBQ chicken, Margherita, and a couple other options). We ordered a Buffalo milk to start which was SO good (basically a banana nutella shake with vodka). Then we ordered the breakaway wagyu beef sliders with fries. The servers were very attentive and friendly and the food was so good. This was a great place to start our vacation. Even though it was different than we initially expected, we had a really good time.

My family would come here every year. We loved the food and the look of the restaurant with all the signs. The menu had an array of pizzas, pastas and all sorts of Italian fare. My favorite was the casino chips. This year we went for dinner and they had drastically changed their menu. It was really pared down, they probably had about a quarter of what they usually had. My pasta was ok but not great, it was a bit disappointing. I really miss the old menu and wish they would bring it back.

The food was so good! We each got a pizza. We shared the cesaer salad, fried artichoke, and cheezy garlic bread. We had just finished the TCT and this was our first real meal in 5 days. It was pricy but you can't put a price on happiness. This place has delicious food. Service wasn't the best, however, Issrreal was killing it with the great service. He wasn't even our server, and he went above and beyond.

I read some negative reviews about this place. So this is review is based on my own personal experience. We were walking around trying to find a place to eat and came across this pizzeria. We ordered 1 clam chowder 1 garlic bread. 2 small pizzas and I got the angus burger with 2 cokes. I paid 95 dollars in total. Please be aware that sodas cost 4.50 each. The food was ok can't complaint when we had such a beautiful view of the beach. Our server was very friendly and got our correct. We will be returning again when we visit the island.