Tavern 1757

Went for brunch. Mimosa selection was great even though they were out of quite a few. Food was blah..choices were limited and not a large quantity. They ran out of eggs....could not get an egg white omelette. There was no replenishment of the salad. The food was nothing special and not worth $20. To reply I never saw steak...that would have been nice. You made it a point to mention my second omelet. I am gluten sensitive and because of that going in I knew my choices would be limited but when you don't even have the staples like eggs to make an omelet that can be an issue. The service was great.

I have had two showers there, one bridal, and one baby. The staff was so easy to work with both before and during the events. The food was very good, many complements received from our guests. The upstairs room is a good size. If weather is nice, there is an outdoors area. I would highly recommend this venue for your banquet needs. Additionally, the main restaurant is a great dinner choice.

We were out for a fun afternoon with my sister's boyfriend's family. They recommended Tavern 1757 because of the positive experiences in the past. I don't know if the incident today was an isolated post-holiday slip or if the quality of this restaurant has since dropped. The food - which took an hour to come in a restaurant serving only two other tables - was not the worst part of the experience, however. Not wanting to embarrass my sister's boyfriend's family, no one complained in house. Instead we wrote a review here on Google which management quickly saw after we left. Unfortunately, the other family had yet to leave and were approached and now embarrassed by an irate manager wanting to know what was wrong with the meal. As someone who has worked in the food service business for several years, I don't know how this place can be as bad as this. I don't post many Google reviews, but customers should know about this incident. Maybe my definition of quality food differs from the next person, but confronting customers like this is upsetting, embarrassing, and unnecessary.

The worst dining experience ever. Music too loud, soup cold, crab cakes like hockey pucks and clams that were also cold. This place hardly has edible food. Service was terrible. Took a half hour to get cold soup and another twenty minutes to get substandard main. Oh boy!! Sad to say as I so want to support local business but can’t this time. Hope they improve.

Beautiful atmosphere. The staff were very pleasant, as well as accommodating. The food was amazing!! I would highly recommend for a nice dinner, a small gathering (where your party is seated in a gorgeous wine celler), or a reception (the reception room is equally aesthetically pleasing!). Five starts all around!