Il Fornaio

I had previously dined at the Sacramento location and was pleasantly surprised to discover there was one in Carmel. To say that my experience at the Carmel location exceeded my expectations would be an understatement. From the moment we arrived, the host welcomed us with a warm and friendly demeanor, promptly checking us in. Despite it being a busy night at the restaurant, our waiter managed to accommodate us swiftly and with a cheerful attitude. The food, without a doubt, was a highlight. Everything we ordered was fantastic, but the tiramisu and setteveli deserve a special mention – they are both incredibly delicious and shouldn't be missed! This has quickly become my favorite Italian restaurant in the area. I'm looking forward to returning more frequently. The exceptional service, delicious food, and welcoming atmosphere make it a top-notch choice.

They don’t always seat outdoors but when they do, it’s beautiful. A deck surrounded by bright colored flowers. They have an excellent vegan minestrone soup (better than other Il Fornaio locations which I have seen omit beans) and another vegan avocado salad/grain item on the menu also! Grateful to have this in Carmel.

We have dined at three different Il Fornaio locations over the years. Of all, none compare to the standard of excellence we experienced each visit at their Pine Inn Carmel location. Hosting a recent party of 7 prominent local residents, from the time we arrived till leaving a memorable evening of 5Star service food and hospitality we give a very special shout out to our server Kathy!!! As a tourist and as locals Carmel’s Il Fornaio is a must for a delightful Carmel experience!

So funny story, there is two il fornaio’s in Carmel and I had made reservations for this place but accidentally went to their second location. The experience was super lovely! My boyfriend and I were celebrating our one year and the waiter actually gave us celebratory champagne which was suuuuper yummy. I had gotten the delicious fish special and my boyfriend got the three meat pasta which he really enjoyed. If that place was good I can not wait to try this correct location 🤣

Food was delicious, it was a little slow but that's not surprising they seemed understaffed for a weekend. Our waitress was super patient and explained the menu items well! We ordered the Burrata Con Prosciutto, the Ossobuco Di Maiale (pork shank), and the Cannelloni pasta, all were delicious! They have a 3% surcharge on current prices as well.

Beautiful restaurant with lovely ambiance and great service .Dogs are welcome on the rooftop and there is a handicap accessible entrance. We sat on the rooftop which was gorgeous. Flowers all around and plenty of heaters if you get cold. Our server Ramon was fantastic and very attentive. He definitely added to our good experience by suggesting meals and wines to compliment. I love all the seating options for if you want a more casual dinner or something fancier. The brussel sprouts starter was delicious. I had the gnocchi and would order it again for sure. I don't think I'd take my kids here because it felt more like a date night atmosphere but I'll definitely go back and recommend to visitors.