Pie

Amazing staff and great service. Full bar with lots of speciality drinks. Homemade infused vodka and tequila. We tried 2 pizzas and the first one was not so good but the second one came out amazing....the only difference was we added sausage. Tough to rate. The house salad was done well and very good.

We have been to Bethany every summer but had not yet visited Pie. We went last weekend in November 2021 and had such a great experience dining in. The restaurant is casual with a good vibe and good music and our waitress was very friendly and helpful. She was on her own and helping with carry out but made sure we had a great experience. The food was so amazing! We had the meatballs which cannot be skipped! They were delicious. The pizza was fresh and the sauce was fantastic -we got gluten free crust which was amazing. To top it off we did the blueberry pie which was over the top good. We highly recommend and will be visiting regularly!!!

Went in... late in the season... late September.... had a long day but we were just riding by on our bikes and we just happen to see the "pie" sign and thought... we haven't had a good 'za in a while.... well, our prayers were answered!! Kickass dough, sauce and toppers....matched with perfect beer.... our server was sweet, unassuming and very cool!! Thank you so much pie!!