Best Restaurants in West Islip

📋 Menu ⭐ Top

★ 95 /100

View →

Bella Cucina

💬 1510 reviews

📍 424 Montauk Hwy

🍴

⭐ Top

★ 95 /100

View →

Teresa's Pizza

💬 88 reviews

📍 5 Udall Rd

📋 Menu ⭐ Top

★ 94 /100

View →

Hometown Heroes

Italian American

💬 636 reviews

📍 240 Higbie Ln

⭐ Top

★ 91 /100

View →

Paradise Saloon

💬 70 reviews

📍 12 Hawley Ave

📋 Menu ⭐ Top

★ 90 /100

View →

Higbie Heros

Deli

💬 600 reviews

📍 240 Higbie Ln

🍴

⭐ Top

★ 90 /100

View →

Mona Lisa Of Long Island

💬 86 reviews

📍 5 Udall Rd

🍴

⭐ Top

★ 90 /100

View →

House Of Juice

💬 70 reviews

📍 187 Sunrise Highway, Suite C

📋 Menu

★ 90 /100

View →

Brownstones Coffee

American Cafe

💬 1287 reviews

📍 306 Union Blvd

📋 Menu

★ 89 /100

View →

Higbie Bagels

Cafe

💬 1283 reviews

📍 264 Higbie Ln

★ 89 /100

View →

7-eleven

💬 42 reviews

📍 174 Higbie Ln

📋 Menu

★ 88 /100

View →

Our Little Italy

💬 1422 reviews

📍 636 Union Blvd

★ 88 /100

View →

Monte Di Procida Ristorante & Pizzeria

Italian Pizza

💬 19 reviews

📍 424 Montauk Hwy

★ 86 /100

View →

West Islip Hot Bagels

Cafe

💬 172 reviews

📍 544 Hunter Ave

📋 Menu

★ 86 /100

View →

Carvel

💬 99 reviews

📍 794 Udall Rd

📋 Menu

★ 85 /100

View →

Crispino

💬 3817 reviews

📍 159 Higbie Ln

📋 Menu

★ 85 /100

View →

Summerwind Gourmet Deli & Catering

💬 183 reviews

📍 434 Montauk Hwy

📋 Menu

★ 85 /100

View →

Besito Mexican Restaurant

Mexican Latin

💬 1543 reviews

📍 399 Montauk Hwy

📋 Menu

★ 84 /100

View →

Best Kitchen

💬 288 reviews

📍 787 Udall Rd

🍴

★ 84 /100

View →

Someplace Else

💬 64 reviews

📍 226 Higbie Ln

🍴

★ 83 /100

View →

Chiddy's Cheesesteaks Of West Islip

💬 399 reviews

📍 510 Union Blvd