Gencarelli's

Name: Gencarelli's
Address: 58 Lake Dr W, Wayne, 07470-5733, US
Telephone: +1 973-633-0099
Rating: 3.6

58 Lake Dr W, 07470-5733 - Wayne

Updated on 05 Jun 2025

Italian Pizza

★★★★★ ★★★★★

3.6/5

736 recommendations

+12

3.6/5

Sluurpometro: 72/100

Sluurpy Score

736 total reviews

TA Trip

3.5/5

14 reviews

G Google

3.6/5

125 reviews

F Facebook

3.9/5

2 reviews

G Grubhub

3.0/5

569 reviews

S Slice

4.0/5

26 reviews

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 973-633-0099

🌐 Website: http://store5.geomerx.com/gencarellisonthelake/

📍 Address: 58 Lake Dr W, Wayne

🕐 Opening Hours

Closed Opens at 06:00 AM

Monday1 06:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Tuesday2 06:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Wednesday3 06:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Thursday4 06:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Friday5 06:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Saturday6 06:00 AM - 06:00 PM

Sunday7 06:00 AM - 08:00 PM

🍽️ Menu - Full Menu

📷 Photos (10+)

+2
more photos

Google Reviews

3.6/5

★★★★★

125 Google reviews

Kristin Alvarez

5 months ago

★★★★★ 5/5

I had the drunken grandma pizza pie deal for $17 and upon tasting it, I knew right away this was the best around. The combination between the crust the cheese and the vodka sauce the balance was absolutely perfect. The texture was crunchy on the outside and cooked to perfection on the inside. I had about a 15 minute wait once I arrived but it was well worth the wait. Perfection isn’t instant.

Google

Jeanne F

4 months ago

★★★★★ 5/5

Wanted to place a large order on short notice. I placed the order online and was called within minutes to discuss a change due to short notice. The young lady who called was very helpful in addressing the timeframe and the item replacement. Food was delivered early, there were ample portions and recipients said it was delicious. Thank you for helping to comfort and feed our friends at a very difficult time.

Google

R Lopez

a month ago

★★★★★ 5/5

Simply the best in all they do. Their food & flavor is perfection and cannot be duplicated. Marinara sauce, etc.. A++ Open 7 days. Easy access Routes 46, 80, 280.

Google

Ivette Chira

8 months ago

★★☆☆☆ 2/5

What can I say about this place. For starters I have come home from work 2 times to have food left on my stoop because they confuse my address with someone else’s! Both times I have driven the food to the correct place. Luckily down the street. Food is good but the service lacks..I have ordered dinner to be picked up a bunch. A few times it hasn’t even been prepared when my husband or I get there to pick it up! As I type this my husband is there waiting to pick up and order that I placed an hour ago. They said 20 min…he got there and it wasn’t even ready. I’m not sure what is happening but they need to get it together, I have not typed up a review because the food is good but this was the last straw. I won’t be ordering again

Google

Joe Just joe

11 months ago

★★★☆☆ 3/5

Was told by my daughter in law the food is good. But after reading some of the reviews I’m a bit hesitant to order for a family party. I see lots of apologies from the owners on the same issues cold food bad delivery times poor customer service and they will work to improve them. But over the time frame nothing seems to be improved. With a 3.5 rating that’s merely average.. I can get average food anywhere. Think I’ll have to pass. I thank everyone for taking the time for their reviews it helped me make up my mind. Seems lots improvement is needed and less apologies.

Google

Hana Sela

a month ago

★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

The front desk was very mean and rude! Kept rolling my eyes at me. Never had a worse front desk person ever. Would not take my coupon...like???

Google

Kitti L.

3 years ago

★★★★★ 5/5

They made a cake for my son's birthday. I had a full sheet cake and they did a killer job. Sure, I could have saved a little money if I got a Costco cake but I heard Gencarelli's had great tasting cakes... They did not disappoint. I will definitely use them again.

Google

Ron Agresta

7 months ago

★★★☆☆ 3/5

Ordered a grandma pie & a regular pie both half plain & half sausage. Delovery was a bit long, about an hour and a half. The grandma pie was outstanding but had very little sausage on it. The plain pie was just ok but came with pepperoni instead of sausage like we ordered.

Google

Explore more in Wayne

By cuisine

Recommended pages

Help improve this page:

← Back to all restaurants in Wayne

Gencarelli's