Best Restaurants in Sayville

🍴

⭐ Top

★ 100 /100

View →

Brunch Sayville

💬 1 reviews

📍 32 Foster Avenue

⭐ Top

★ 100 /100

View →

The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

💬 1 reviews

📍 98 Main St

📋 Menu ⭐ Top

★ 95 /100

View →

Sal's Pizza

Italian Pizza

💬 345 reviews

📍 183 W Main St

⭐ Top

★ 95 /100

View →

J & B Prestano Bakery

💬 161 reviews

📍 71 Main St

⭐ Top

★ 93 /100

View →

Sassyfrass Restaurant

American Bar Cafe

💬 2987 reviews

📍 Fire island National seashore

⭐ Top

★ 93 /100

View →

Cornucopia Natural Foods

💬 188 reviews

📍 39 N Main St

⭐ Top

★ 92 /100

View →

Oversouth Tavern And Grille

Pub

💬 80 reviews

📍 209 Railroad Ave

⭐ Top

★ 90 /100

View →

Sweetfrog

💬 287 reviews

📍 5640-35 Sunrise Highway

📋 Menu

★ 89 /100

View →

Sayville Inn

American Bar Pub

💬 410 reviews

📍 199 Middle Rd

📋 Menu

★ 89 /100

View →

American Cheese

American

💬 363 reviews

📍 289 Railroad Ave

📋 Menu

★ 87 /100

View →

Landmark Deli

Deli

💬 227 reviews

📍 371 Lakeland Ave

📋 Menu

★ 87 /100

View →

The Portly Villager

Brew Pub Pub

💬 534 reviews

📍 261 W Main St

📋 Menu

★ 87 /100

View →

Toa

Japanese

💬 1252 reviews

📍 239 N Main St

📋 Menu

★ 86 /100

View →

Sobol

Cafe

💬 396 reviews

📍 153 Main St

📋 Menu

★ 86 /100

View →

Off The Block

American

💬 930 reviews

📍 501 Montauk Highway

📋 Menu

★ 86 /100

View →

Cenote Modern Mexican

💬 58 reviews

📍 45 Foster Ave

★ 85 /100

View →

Fritzsche's Bakery

💬 190 reviews

📍 56 Main St

📋 Menu

★ 85 /100

View →

Cherry Grove Pizza

Pizza

💬 222 reviews

📍 179 Ocean Walk

★ 85 /100

View →

Umberto's

American Pizza Italian

💬 1440 reviews

📍 37 N Main St

📋 Menu

★ 84 /100

View →

La Tavola

Italian

💬 824 reviews

📍 183 W Main St