Star Tavern

The pizza tastes great and is always made fresh. The style of pizza has a thinner type of crust so you'll end up eating more than you might usually eat somewhere else. If thin crust isn't your style, this isn't your place. The wings also taste good. Good amount of crisp and soaked in buffalo sauce. The place can be pretty pricey though and they're consistently understaffed on weekends. There's only ever two.. maybe three, waiters walking around and it's clear they're always busy. With that being said though, they still do a great job. You'll just end up waiting a bit longer for some things. Some dishes seem to be over priced for what they are... But in the pizza department, prices are totally fine.

When I lived in New Jersey this was a regular visit. Now it's a treat; I'm happy to report it's still as excellent as ever. It's not fancy - but the pizza is an art. The rest of the food menu is excellent too - don't sleep on it. Get a pitcher of Sierra Nevada, order a few thin crust pies, and enjoy.

If your a fan of burnt crust pizza, Star taverns your place. Not well done… we’re talking straight asphalt black burnt. So black it’s almost purple if the light hits right. So black the police followed me for 3 blocks. Thought it was just a one time thing but this is the 3rd time. Guess it’s the new wave. Still tastes good just avoid the crust.

Overhyped and over priced. I ordered because a group of people from my job were ordering out for lunch. We heard that they were really good. I ordered a shrimp Ceasar salad that came with three small shrimp on it for $14.00+. Then they don’t deliver and they forgot to put my salad in the bag for the Togo order. I had to drive all the way back to get the salad and I was very disappointed with the salad once I did get it. I am also pregnant so you know how pregnant people don’t play about their food. This ruined my experience and I never want to eat here again.

We went to lunch after doing an installation job in west Orange. One of the employee who is a friend of ours recommended Star Tavern and we sat down immediately. There is a nice waiter who seemed to be managing all of the tables. There were about 40 people eating lunch. Can’t wait to taste the pizza. Regular pizza joint atmosphere with a Bar. The bartender seemed nice from the way she handled her clients at the bar. The pizza was great. We ordered a portobello with pine nuts with dried tomatoes and we kicked up a notch with hot peppers 🌶