Best Restaurants in Islamorada

Discover 106 restaurants with browsable menus, verified reviews and prices. Complete guide updated April 2026.

⭐

76/100

Avg Rating

🍴

29

Cuisine Types

20 of 106 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Keys Chocolates & Ice Cream

Keys Chocolates & Ice Cream

💬 136 reviews

📍 81933 Overseas Hwy

Meat Eatery And Taproom

Meat Eatery And Taproom

💬 2646 reviews

📍 88005 Overseas Hwy

El Framboyan Cuban Cuisine

El Framboyan Cuban Cuisine

💬 424 reviews

📍 82751 Overseas Hwy

Cafe Moka Islamorada

Cafe Moka Islamorada

French Cafe European

💬 206 reviews

📍 81868 Overseas Hwy

Morada Bay

American Caribbean Seafood

💬 5966 reviews

📍 81600 Overseas Hwy

Green Turtle Inn Restaurant

Green Turtle Inn Restaurant

American Bar Pub

💬 3655 reviews

📍 81219 Overseas Hwy

Mangrove Mike's Cafe

Mangrove Mike's Cafe

American Cafe Diner

💬 4532 reviews

📍 82200 Overseas Hwy

Chef Rolf's Tuna's

Chef Rolf's Tuna's

💬 532 reviews

📍 80939 Overseas Hwy

Oceanside Safari Restaurant

💬 21 reviews

📍 73814 Overseas Hwy

Papa Joe's Waterfront

Papa Joe's Waterfront

📍 79786 Overseas Highway

F-ing Bagels

📍 80925 Overseas Highway

Kaiyo Grill & Sushi Bar

Kaiyo Grill & Sushi Bar

Japanese Seafood Sushi

💬 1493 reviews

📍 81701 Old Hwy

Whale Harbor Sandbar

Whale Harbor Sandbar

💬 237 reviews

📍 83413 Overseas Hwy

Lobster Shack/rain Barrel

Lobster Shack/rain Barrel

💬 1008 reviews

📍 86700 Overseas Hwy

Ciao Hound

Ciao Hound

Italian Pizza Seafood

💬 1270 reviews

📍 84001 Overseas Highway

Abel's Tackle Box And General Goods

Abel's Tackle Box And General Goods

💬 184 reviews

📍 84000 Overseas Hwy

Lazy Days

American Caribbean Bar

💬 14358 reviews

📍 79867 Overseas Hwy

Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar

Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar

American Bar Seafood

💬 13844 reviews

📍 Mile Marker 82

Chef Michael's

American Seafood

💬 2878 reviews

📍 81671 Overseas Highway

The Whistle Stop Bar & Grill And Wood Oven Pizza

The Whistle Stop Bar & Grill And Wood Oven Pizza

Bar Pub American

💬 734 reviews

📍 82685 Overseas Hwy.

🍴

Explore by Cuisine Type

American 33 Seafood 24 Bar 11 Cafe 9 Caribbean 6 Asian 4 Pub 4 Contemporary 3 Soups 3 Barbecue 2 Chinese 2 Cuban 2 Fast Food 2 French 2 Italian 2 Japanese 2 Latin 2 Mexican 2 Pizza 2 Sushi 2 Caucasian 1 Deli 1 Diner 1 European 1 Grill 1 Healthy 1 Mediterranean 1 Middle Eastern 1 Spanish 1

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📋

38 Browsable Menus

📅

Apr 2026 Last Updated