Best Restaurants in Florida Keys

Discover 15 restaurants with browsable menus, verified reviews and prices. Complete guide updated May 2026.

⭐

91/100

Avg Rating

🍴

17

Cuisine Types

15 of 15 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Fresh Press Express

📍 87951 Overseas Hwy

Sea Grapes Wine Bar & Bistro

Sea Grapes Wine Bar & Bistro

Deli Wine Bar Bar

💬 157 reviews

📍 80925 Overseas Hwy Unit 3

Anglers Islamorada And Live Bait

Anglers Islamorada And Live Bait

💬 216 reviews

📍 90515 Old Hwy

Islamorada Latin Cafe

Islamorada Latin Cafe

Caribbean Latin Cafe

💬 188 reviews

📍 90270 Overseas Hwy

Good Girl Juice & Cafe

Good Girl Juice & Cafe

💬 134 reviews

📍 81868 Overseas Hwy

Dixie Dharma

💬 515 reviews

📍 2603 E South St

Galley Girls Cafe

Galley Girls Cafe

American Seafood

💬 140 reviews

📍 79851 Overseas Hwy

Overseas Kitchen

Overseas Kitchen

Mediterranean Greek

💬 584 reviews

📍 82205 Overseas Hwy

Reefers Gastropub

Reefers Gastropub

Brew Pub Seafood Pub

💬 170 reviews

📍 105 Palm Ave

Don Pedro's

Don Pedro's

💬 71 reviews

Kev's Cafe

Kev's Cafe

💬 37 reviews

📍 79851 Overseas Hwy

Lobster Crawl Bar & Grill

Lobster Crawl Bar & Grill

American Bar Seafood

💬 923 reviews

📍 70001 Overseas Hwy

Zane Grey Lounge

Zane Grey Lounge

American Bar Seafood

💬 367 reviews

📍 81576 Overseas Highway

Mexicana Morada Restaurant

Mexicana Morada Restaurant

Mexican Latin Spanish

💬 327 reviews

📍 82751 Overseas Hwy

Nicky's Grill

Nicky's Grill

💬 818 reviews

📍 84721 Overseas Hwy

🍴

Explore by Cuisine Type

American 4 Seafood 4 Bar 3 Cafe 2 Latin 2 Pub 2 Spanish 2 Wine Bar 2 Brew Pub 1 Caribbean 1 Cuban 1 Deli 1 Gastropub 1 Greek 1 Healthy 1 Mediterranean 1 Mexican 1

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📋

5 Browsable Menus

📅

May 2026 Last Updated