🍴 Pizza ✕

Pizza Restaurants in Brewster

Discover 12 pizza restaurants with browsable menus, verified reviews and prices. Complete guide updated April 2026.

🍴

20

Cuisine Types

12 of 12 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Taormina's Pizzeria-ristorante

Taormina's Pizzeria-ristorante

💬 295 reviews

📍 278 N Brewster Rd

Aversano's

$$ - $$$ 💬 576 reviews

📍 1620 Route 22

Moonlight Cafe

Moonlight Cafe

American Pizza Cafe

💬 134 reviews

📍 850 Route 22

Pizza Place And Trattoria Ii

$ 💬 1775 reviews

📍 35 Main St

Sinapi's Pizzeria

Sinapi's Pizzeria

$$ - $$$ 💬 256 reviews

📍 1583 Route 22

Five Brothers Pizza & Pasta

Five Brothers Pizza & Pasta

$$ - $$$ 💬 527 reviews

📍 2505 Carmel Ave

Stone L'oven Pizza Co.

Stone L'oven Pizza Co.

Italian Pizza American

$$ - $$$ 💬 932 reviews

📍 280 Underpass Rd

Portofinos Pizza & Pasta

Portofinos Pizza & Pasta

$ 💬 298 reviews

📍 983 Route 22

Gaetano Pizza

Gaetano Pizza

$ 💬 764 reviews

📍 100 Independent Way

Mezzaluna Pizzeria And Restaurant

Mezzaluna Pizzeria And Restaurant

$$ - $$$ 💬 412 reviews

📍 1511 New York 22

Brewster Pizza House & Sports Bar

Brewster Pizza House & Sports Bar

$ 💬 1008 reviews

📍 2655 Main St

Laurino's Tavern

Laurino's Tavern

American Bar Italian

$$ - $$$ 💬 949 reviews

📍 3668 Main St

🍴

Explore by Cuisine Type

American 39 Pizza 12 Italian 11 Bar 10 Seafood 9 Pub 7 Mexican 6 Cafe 5 Fast Food 5 Deli 4 Diner 3 Soups 3 Asian 2 Chinese 2 French 2 Japanese 2 Sushi 2 Contemporary 1 European 1 Greek 1

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📊

0 Reviews Analyzed

🏆

0 Top Restaurants

📋

0 Browsable Menus

📅

Apr 2026 Last Updated