Millrock Restaurant

I went in expecting nothing impressive, but was blown away. We started with their burrata dish, which was good. Nothing crazy there. Then had the lemon chicken and the chicken Marsala. The lemon chicken was good, but a bit bland. The Marsala was really the star. Super flavorful. Ended with the seasonal lemon cheesecake, which was delightful. They remind me of a childhood noonis house and cooking. There is no salt on the table 😂 because it's supposed to be good as is. If I make it back to the Catskills, I will be sure to stop by again.

We celebrated our wedding rehearsal dinner at Millrock this summer and it was an exceptional experience every step of the way. From the planning process to the event itself, Eddie, his family, and the staff at Millrock were so accommodating, warm, and kind. The food and service was incredible. Eddie arranged a family style meal at our request and everyone raved about each delicious course. Their team ensured there was always food and drink on the table and everyone was well taken care of. But most importantly, Eddie communicated with us every step of the way and made us feel welcome as if we were family. We can’t thank him, his parents, and the Millrock team enough!

Love Millrock! One of our favorite go to spots in Windham… One of the only places we can get broccoli rabe on the regular. The waitstaff is always on point especially Alexis and we love the company of Eddie and the whole team. John will also always hold a special place in my heart and will always consider them great people and phenomenal hosts…

Dishes we ordered were mediocre good. We felt that main dishes could use a bit more salt/seasoning. Service was great. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. She checked on us frequently. They have indoor and outdoor seating. Go early because they do fill up quickly and they don't take reservations. We waited for 20 mins, which is not too bad. There is a service charge for credit card, which I think they forgot to inform us.

If you go here, ask for Paul! He was absolutely the best waiter. I’ve had ever! (Coming from a former waitress.) the food was absolutely amazing. The atmosphere was lovely and intimate. The place was packed so if you can make a reservation do so it’s worth the wait! A little pricey, but definitely worth it more so than the other places around. The food had an abundance of flavor and we had such a great time even in the rain definitely a must try spot if you’re in Windham.

We had such a great time at Millrock. The food was yummy, the vibe was great, and the service was incredible. Our server Paul, was the best! The owner made a stop or two at our table as well. Really down to earth people who clearly know how to make their customers happy and comfortable. We'll definitely be returning the next time we crave Italian/Pizza!