First time visiting this pizzeria restaurant. It was great! Very busy night though during pasta night. It's best if you make a reservation. I didn't give service 5 stars because our server did forget one dish and we had a family member waiting for it for a bit, but i approached the waiter and she apologized. The food was delicious the pasta dishes were big it was definitely worth the price and the time!
J
James Thomas
Google
a month ago
5.0
Best Italian Restaurant in Central Suffolk, possibly all of Suffolk and possibly all of Nassau too. As a matter of fact… I think they have Queens beaten too. I don’t eat in the other boroughs. We may be talking about the best Italian Restaurant on the Western Hemisphere! Everything is delicious! Try it if you haven’t. You won’t be disappointed.
M
Marybeth Spano
Google
a week ago
5.0
Always a great experience. Food, atmosphere does not dissappoint. Just wish there was another restaurant closer to my home, but will travel anyway
E
Executive Group Realty
Google
a year ago
4.0
Excellent service, friendly and attentive staff. The parking lot offers plenty of parking. The linguini pescatore came out too hot to eat, and because it was so hot, the pasta overcooked in the dish and it wasn't enjoyable to eat.
U
Uncle Bishoppe's Kitchen
Google
a year ago
5.0
This place has the best food. The best servers and the atmosphere is amazing. Everyone is laughing and enjoying the food and spirits. They also have an Italian dude who comes in and sings all the classics. I take my wife all the time. I always give a big tip because they really earn it. Always smiles and helpful. They even take reservations and always honor them. Other places will take a reservation and act like they had no clue you were coming. This place is the best of the best, where the best come from.
A
Alison Elizabeth
Google
a year ago
5.0
Absolutely delicious authentic Italian cuisine. Wonderful service, portions are tremendous, and everything tasted delicious. Joe is very attentive to his patrons and sees to it that everyone is enjoying their experience.
T
Theresa Fitzpatrick
Google
a year ago
5.0
The food and the service was impeccable. I highly recommend. The waitress was excellent. Loved everything 5 ⭐ in my book
S
Shawn Noonan
Google
2 months ago
5.0
MAN! that was good! I’m so stuffed! Pasta allaVodka with meat was fantastic, minestrone soup, garlic knots and red velvet cake with raspberry sauce and shaved chocolate! I would put this place as one of my top 3 of all time. Service was great!
A
Anne DeSimone
Google
2 months ago
5.0
Caffe Amici is fabulous! The waitress went out of her way to check to see how a particular menu item was prepared. She was patient and attentive. The food was delicious and the portions were large enough to share.
L
laura G
Google
2 months ago
4.0
the food is amazing, the only thing i could complain about is the minestrone soup is nottttttt minestrone soup .. it was just a huge piece of cauliflower, celery and a carrot in tomato broth, very strange didn’t want to eat it, and disapointed .. they should change it on the menu to just Vegetable Soup .. or just simply add some beans/pasta to it and make it more like Minestrone.
E
Ed cernyar
Google
3 months ago
5.0
If i could have given 10 stars for service, I would have. The front counter team was extremely friendly and helpful. I walk with a cane and ordered a couple of pies , soda, and knots he didn't skip a beat, but no sooner than when i finished paying, he was already around the counter carrying my order out to the car
M
Maria Vilardi
Google
4 months ago
5.0
Mr. Jonathan didn’t know how to make a Espresso Martini however he asked for assistance from Amanda. Excellent drink and got I got 2. Well done from both. Last time I was here wasn’t happy but I like this place and them both made sure I was pleased.
E
Elizabeth Fuentes
Google
5 months ago
5.0
I love italian food and this restaurant have amazing pasta and the sangria is really good and the dessert so delicious. the price is reasonable, service was good they are friendly and nice
S
Stacey Stephenson
Google
5 months ago
5.0
Great restaurant. Had my boss’s retirement party there and we had no complaints. Been there for lunch numerous times. The price is very reasonable for the portion size. I love the tortellini alla panna. There’s so many options. There’s a man with glasses who works there, I assume the manager, is always polite and makes sure his guests are taken care of.
D
Darryl Brooks
Google
8 months ago
5.0
We went on pasta night. I had the lasagna, and a side of sausage. Nice portions, we all brought food home. Everyone was happy with their meals. Our waitress was amazing she was very attentive, and friendly. Thank you Michelle!
