Lt Burger

TL;DR: Tiny tacos, big prices, great drinks and vibe. I was tempted to give this place three stars, but the decoration and vibe pushed it to four stars. My companion and I discovered this place while walking around the super scenic Sag Harbor Main Street on a Saturday afternoon. We were seated immediately and provided with paper menus that listed their tacos, bowls, appetizers, and drinks. I wanted to try either their al pastor or pork belly bowl, but our server informed me that they don’t have bowls yet as they’ve only been open a week. Why not cross off the bowls on your disposable, paper menus? After that slight bit of disappointment I settled for the al pastor and pork belly tacos. We ordered a side of chips and guac. Had I immediately noticed their $22 price I probably would’ve ordered something else, but we stuck with it… and that was a good decision. The tacos are closer to a traditional Mexican size and not the beefier tacos most Americans are accustomed to. Upon seeing the tacos my companion said “I see why they make you two order at least two.” We noticed that I’d received a fish taco in place of the al pastor. I tried to flag down our server and a manager(?) came to the table instead and said that he could help with whatever we wanted. I asked the server to read back what I ordered (in case they heard differently) and I did indeed order an al pastor. The manager person said I could keep the fist taco and an al pastor taco was brought to the table a few minutes later. TASTE: The chips and guac were delicious and filling, which was appreciated since the tacos are on the diminutive side. The al pastor taco was dry and underwhelming. Disappointing. Pork belly taco: The star of the show! Tender and flavorful. A must have. Fish taco: It’s your typical fried fish taco. Nice flavor. Lobster taco: Pricey but great. It’s kinda’ gooey and will squirt out the other end if you don’t hold it properly. Lobster meat flavor was delicious. Shrimp taco: It was okay.

Their Burger and everything was 5 stars, but the hostess (or the owner) was rude enough to not even try to help us when we asked them if we could leave our bags with no responsibility asked for. I get that she might not want to take responsibility, but she offered us to left those into the back yard, following with saying there are lots homeless people who can steal. Dude, the next store literally was 1/5 size and were still nicer to trying to help at least. Ugh

Food was very tasty — got the fried pickles and beyond burger (slightly modified to have a real bun and dairy cheese). Taking off a star since we waited a considerable amount of time for our food and it was also pretty noisy as far as atmosphere goes. Wish we had more of an appetite for shakes, they sounded delicious!