Theo's Taverna

We were excited to try this restaurant due to wide selection different from other restaurants in the area but were severely disappointed… My husband had the worst duck we’ve ever had. It was damn near inedible. It tasted old as if it were cooked days ago and close to going bad. I had the fried grouper which was soggy. Thought maybe the dessert would at least be decent but to our dismay the Tiramisu came out with mold on it (which my husband didn’t notice until eating much of it)! This is so sad as our waitress was pleasant and the atmosphere is wonderful. This restaurant seems like a prime example of what should be on Kitchen Nightmares. It’s the worst restaurant we’ve tried, especially with the high price tag… Wished we would’ve read the other reviews before trying this place out and just thankful we didn’t get severely sick.

I love going to Theo's! The food was superb! The atmosphere & staff is wonderful. I ordered the soup & sandwich. It was Lemon Chicken soup with a Chicken Salad sandwich. The soup has a bright taste with the lemon ; as well as being a comforting bowl of soup. Very tasty. The sandwich was excellent! Chocolate cake topped off our meal. It was perfect & rich.

We ate outside and the atmosphere is very nice. Lots of statues, ambient lighting, candles on the tables, and beautiful. The waitress was very knowledgeable and helpful. The food was good and the complimentary bread was yummy. My only complaint was after my daughter ordered, we found out several minutes later that they were out of that special for the day. No problem but I don't like to pay premium prices to see her disappointed. Later, the same thing happened again with her dessert. Sold out of tiramisu also.

I have never been more humiliated in a restaurant! I came to Theos with another couple with a 5:30 reservation on the patio. The waitress, Martha was awesome. Unfortunately I ordered the baby lamb chops medium rare, but they came out well done. I originally was going to order the lamb loin chop special and was told it was 1 chop so I switched to the 3 on the regular menu. When they came out well done I said I'd rather order the special.... My friend got 2 large chops. 3 minutes later I was told sorry, u got the 3 chops again. She already had them to serve. Shocked I cut into all 3 and they were inedible, fatty, gristly, and raw. I'm assuming they were trying to "teach me a lesson." Not only was I humiliated by the chef but trying to navigate the rest of the meal was torture. I tried to pretend I was fine. The waitress tried her best to recover but I just wanted the night to end. NEVER AGAIN WILL I SET FOOT INTO THIS ESTABLISHMENT!

Such a lovely place. They were very prompt with our drink order but didn't rush us at all - I had a lot of catching up to do with friends of my parents. Loved the decor and the food as well. I had the mousakka - yum! My friend got a fruity cocktail and I got a manhattan - 2 drinks from 2 ends of the spectrum and they were both delicious. They allowed us to stay as long as we wanted to linger.

Lovely, had a late lunch! I enjoyed the beautiful ambiance & delicous authentic Greek food! 💝 Such a beautiful Taverna & lovely garden seating! They also have a dinning room with two beautiful fireplaces! Great Staff & Service, also delicious deserts! I'm really looking forward to dining for Dinner! Bravo Theos💝

Went 2 different days on our 7 day vacation. The first time was amazing from start to finish with Alex as our waiter. The second time was a total bust our server was new and kept apologizing every time she came to the table. Not once did she ask us what we would like to drink, i went to the bar and got my own. We waited way too long after ordering our meals for them to come out. I think the food is awesome. Our waitress shouldn't have been on her own so the service was the worst i have had in a really long time. She was just way too inexperienced not her fault, management shouldn't have allowed that to happen.