Sergio's

Sergio's Italian Restaurant in Pelham, NY, consistently impresses with its excellent service, delicious food, and inviting ambiance. Customers frequently praise the attentive and humorous service provided by the waitstaff, notably mentioning waiters like Tory for their detail-oriented and engaging approach. The dining experience is further enhanced by the cozy and upscale interior, making it suitable for various occasions, from family gatherings to special evenings out. The menu at Sergio's offers a range of delightful Italian dishes that have received positive reviews. Highlights include well-prepared classics like veal, fish, and pasta dishes, which are both excellent in taste and generous in portion. The restaurant also receives special commendation for its homemade desserts, with the espresso martini and the Napolean dessert being particular standouts, praised for their exceptional quality. While the overall experience at Sergio's is highly regarded, the restaurant's location does require street parking, as there is no dedicated parking lot. This is a minor inconvenience but something to be aware of when planning a visit. Overall, Sergio's is celebrated for consistently providing great food and service, making it a must-visit restaurant in the Pelham area for those seeking a high-quality Italian dining experience.

Maybe we ordered wrong. My husband and I came to Sergio's for the first time and had high expectations based on reviews. Unfortunately, neither of us enjoyed our entree much. The pasta with porcini sauce was thick and gluey. So heavy I could not eat more than a few bites. The pasta with clams was very bland. We enjoyed our salad with pears and gorgonzola. There was also an extremely loud patron arguing with another diner at their table. The argument continued very loud and I could tell the wait staff noticed and hovered a little nearby but never did anything about it. It made the meal very unpleasant. Otherwise, the physical ambiance is very nice. And extra points for a really good jazzy trumpet player who came out and played for birthdays.

One of the finest dining experiences we have ever had. I had a chicken and sausage dish that was delicious, and the fish dishes are fresh and exceptional. The timing of the food being brought to the table is perfect. The food always comes out piping hot. The wait staff is attentive without being overbearing. Sergio’s is a must dine destination in lower Westchester.

Beautiful space, good food, and quality service, Tori was our server. You could tell they take pride in their service, ensuring we were enjoying the dinner. ..all the details were en point. Def will be returning, and I loved the music! Andrea Bocceli, Zucchero, Eros Ramazoti.... transported me back to the 90s .

Nick and the entire Sergios team were amazing! My bridal shower was held upstairs for approximately 35 people and it was absolutely perfect. The food was incredible the staff was attentive and all of the guests couldn't stop gushing over what an amazing time they had. Nick suggested a local bakery in the Bronx for the cake which was delicious and delivered directly to the restaurant! I've been to Sergio's several times for dinner, and so incredibly happy that we decided to have the shower there too. It never fails!! If you're looking for the perfect place to have your first family get together in 18 months ... go with Sergio's!!