Blue Bay Diner

After reading mixed reviews we decided to try this spot We ended up dining at our favorite place in Queens Choosing the right Diner in NYC is hard but this place is the one. Came for breakfast and dinner separate occasions and it was amazing each time. Corned beef hash seriously I wanted to take an order on the plane to bring it home and enjoy even more. My wife had some amazing omelette avocado. The kids menu was great and great portions. Our dinner experience was great also. We had pastas 4 different types and each one was spectacular. Leave space for dessert because I asked and they make their own in house desserts. Cheesecake was amazing. Strawberry shortcake for my daughter was amazing. My favorite hands down dessert was the pumpkin cheesecake. If it’s on display make sure you grab piece when your dining and a piece to go home. Amazing service constant refills and the vibe was amazing.

When i first arrive at the location, bombarded with people. Very busy on a sunday. Didn't like the tone of the person who was in charge of takeout order. But i understand he's super busy and wasn't intentional. Aside from that the waitress was full of smile and was waitressing w| great joy. The food was really good. Beautifully cooked and the presentation was great. I will definitely return for sure.

I love diners. They have their own spirit. On a rainy day we only order a hot matzo ball soup. It was good,my son order a burger he was happy with that . A bit pricey. $50 for 3 soup and a burger. But they serve big portions. The bread (challah) must be really good I can tell,because my kids finish it in a second. I didn’t try any desserts but all looks very delicious! I loved the light jazz music… Service was really fast and parking easy.

Been coming here with family for what feels like decades. Everything on the menu I’ve tried since has ranged from good to fantastic, haven’t been let down once! The burgers are big and juicy, fries cooked perfectly, great breakfast options, even the roumanian steak is delicious. It was sad when the diner exterior became red instead of blue after a renovation 😢