Spring Mill Cafe

A five star experience! Charming ambience in an 1800s farmhouse with a french home style theme. Amanda and Nathan made excellent recommendations and are extremely attentive as well as friendly. We had the large cheese board as an app; pork and lamb stew for main entrees ( best pork I ever had! very juicy and the sauce was divine); orange cake and sorbet with macaroons for dessert as we were celebrating my birthday! It was a wonderful evening and we look forward to returning in the years to come.

I recently had my bridal shower at Spring Mill and it was perfect! Ezra was so helpful and responsive through the entire planning process. He made it a breeze and happily answered ALL of my questions. I even emailed Ezra the week of to add on a plate for a guest who was coming towards the end of the shower. The meal was ready to go when they got there. The venue itself is so quaint and cozy. I specifically chose Spring Mill because I didn’t want a cookie cutter venue with average food. The food on the menu was out of this world and everyone raved about how delicious it was! The staff that worked the shower was attentive and never left us with an empty drink! I highly recommend Spring Mill Cafe for any event or night out! You will not be disappointed! I will add photos as well.

Delicious food. Wonderful ambience. The one flaw? Kim, the hostess. She was immediately rude, unwelcoming, and passive aggressive. We noticed little things, i.e she did not offer to take our coat although she offered that service to other patrons. When we asked if there was a place for us to place our coats, she acted as though by taking them, she was doing us a favor. She was cold and short. Maybe there were something about us that she didn't like; if so, she went out of her way to show it. Thank God for Lauren, our server, and the gentleman who brought our food. They were breaths of fresh air and without Lauren, we would have left immediately. Kim stood behind us banging serverware and glass water bottles, muttering, and being generally unpleasant. Again, she went out of her way to wish other patrons a Happy Valentine's Day. When it was our turn to leave, she turned away and wouldn't open her mouth. Again, Lauren to the rescue. She kindly wished us a Good Evening. Not sure if Kim was jealous, cranky, or unhappy. We might have reminded her of an unpleasant memory. Regardless, she was extremely unprofessional and rude. We also overheard her being very abrupt to a couple whose reservations and couldn't find in the system. She ended up seating them but could've handled them with a bit more grace. Luckily, we had an otherwise pleasant experience. We will probably go again on an evening when that hostess isn't there. If she's there all the time, well, there are other options.

Staff was rude and unwelcoming. I took my mother there for Mother’s Day last year. She was excited to go because one of her favorite actresses shot a film or movie there. When we arrived we weren’t greeted. I waited about five minutes before taking it upon myself to get one of the employees attention. I figured they were busy. But it’s a small place and they appeared to be fully staffed. And everyone that came in after us was greeted and seated as soon as they stepped through the door. So that further confirmed that I wasn’t overthinking, or jumping to conclusions, or being unreasonable in my negative assessment of this restaurant. In regards to the waitress that seated us, her attitude, passive aggression and overall combative demeanor made the experience that my mother was looking further to a disappointing one. We asked to be seated at a table next to the one the waitress selected and she said told us no, it’s reserved. They were many empty tables in there. So her denying us the table we preferred confused us. We had a three course meal and no one never sat at the table we requested while we were in there. Moreover, no one sat at the tables that were alongside the one we preferred during the entirety of our time there. We travelled an hour and a half from NY to dine there. I felt so bad for my mother that this was the experience she had on Mother’s Day.

Outstanding traditional French choices perfectly prepared. It was difficult to make our dinner choices because everything looked wonderful. Fortunately our server helped us make our selections. The staff is professional and kind and the atmosphere is quite pleasant. We enjoyed great service and had some of the tastiest food we’ve had in a long time. We can’t wait to return.