Turtle's Pizza

I took a chance ordering from Turtle’s because of the high rating on slice, and they did NOT disappoint! The chicken Marsala pizza is one of the best I’ve ever had… and that is my favorite pie - so I’ve had many. The sauce is on point, the chicken is tender and the mushrooms plentiful! The hot wings were decent as well. All in all a GREAT first order. ☺️

I’m not sure why this place has only 3.8 stars. There must be another pizzeria having people leave negative reviews. One of them even claimed turtle pizza has the most expensive pizza 🤣 turtle pizza has some of the most competitive and affordable pricing around. It’s why I decided to take a gamble and try them. We had ordered a large plain pizza, Buffalo chicken hero, fries, a pepperoni slice, and a grilled chicken salad. We ordered on a Monday. The slowest day for a restaurant. The food was incredible and super fresh. My friend even took her salad to work the next day and she couldn’t believe how fresh it still was. Highly reccomend.

From what I remember, several years ago the pizza was good and reasonably priced. Today was another story. I called first inquiring about safe and healthy protocol during these difficult times of the Covid19 pandemic. The man who answered said that he was vaccinated ( naturally there’s no proof) so, i decided to go see for myself since he stated that the cook and other staff do follow mask wearing. To my surprise when I walked in the same man who I spoke to in the phone was handling the pizza dough without mask or gloves. When I questioned him why did he mislead me into believing what he told me on the telephone prior to my visit. His reply” everybody gonna die sometime.” I was shocked and walked out.

I give it a star because at least they are trying, but honestly they should shut down. Ninja Turtle Themed Pizzeria? Common. Ordered from here twice. Won’t be coming back. EXTREMELY SALTY, undercooked and bland. And it seems like Constructive Criticism isn’t sticking well because it continues. Guys pack it in. Let a real pizzeria take this location. The Fries are Good. I’ll give you that. I wish you guys a lot of luck.