Fritzsche's Bakery

This is a tiny bakery that you may miss as you drive by. Even the inside is deceiving. Although, IT IS Actually NOT A SMALL BAKERY! The back area where the bakers are is probably 5x's plus Larger Than the bakery itself-where they display the items behind the glass. It's like a little hidden delicious shop. This past Sunday, we arrived at closing time and there were still fresh items to pick up for two different parties that we were going to. The owner is a very hard working person, They all are. I wish I took pictures of the items we purchased. One round bundt chocolate chip cake, Very simple with crumbs on top. That one went over very well at the party!! I also enjoyed it a lot. Then there were angel or elephant ears?? A Large Crispy dessert, must have an Italian name for them.. We got 3, One was partially dipped in dark chocolate. I was ready to dish out over $30. I don't know if it's because it was closing time, I don't believe so, but I'm pretty sure that all those items came out to $21. That's insane. I love Alpine bakery in Smithtown but had I gotten the same items there, it would have been over $30.!!! This bakery is in the beautiful town of Sayville. Maybe a hidden gem or maybe people in the town know about them. It was very impressive. We are definitely going back there! Thank you to the owner/owners who work so hard. Even at closing time, everything we bought was delicious.

This is what you call an old-school Bakery I've been to at least 50 bakeries out here trying to find cookies that had the taste of when I was a kid I knew there had to be one on Long Island I finally found it these cookies are the real deal no grocery store cookie I must have passed this place a dozen times it is very small never even noticed it a neighbor told me about this Bakery and I still had trouble finding it for some reason it never came up on Google thankfully I found it five stars to the Baker and his recipe