Handsome Pizza

Unless you scan the pizza menu hard, you would find out that they don't serve pizza until 4pm...bit of a bummer! Should make that more visible on website // Google. They also have a sign on the curb that displays their pizza, which is odd, since they don't serve it yet. Update to Owners Reply: Please see Hugh Smiths review from 2 years ago. Your set up is confusing and it's unfortunate you can't take the feedback. It was your employee who said they didn't serve pizza until 4pm. But... went to the Thai spot next door & it was amazing!

Awesome place, awesome people, delicious 🍕. And the sea star bakery is good too. They have adapted to take out and ordering with a great website. Support them during this time of isolation, safely by ordering ahead and picking up while wearing a mask. Pictures are of our sausage olive and mama's little peppers pizza.

This bakery is a dream come true. Go to 7th and Bleeker in The Village - as I have regularly for 30 years (and twice in the last six months) - and try arguably the best NY style pizza. Then stay home in Portland and just head up to Killingsworth to eat local pizza that takes it to the next level. So much better with whole grain, sourdough crust that every time is baked to perfection. Just look at the bottom of their pizzas… perfectly even, perfectly browned, never soggy, incredibly thin… somehow it’s always both crisp and chewy with the sourdough/whole grain element taking it off the charts. The baked goods are unique and universally delicious. Too much to discuss here - just go eat them. The weekly dark rye bread is the best ever - packed with big chunks of nuts plus seeds. I used to mill organic rye berries to make my own flour to make sourdough rye bread myself - but going to this bakery is easier, cheaper… and the bread tastes better. Portland rye bread packed with fun textures and no goofy fennel to disguise the rye flavor. I’m mostly vegan - my body doesn’t really approve of either cheese and wheat - but I’m a regular here because the taste and consistency is off the charts. Oh - the red wheat croissants are insane. You may be spoiled for life. This bakery has extreme comfort food for a time that for most isn’t so comfortable. Go enjoy!