I needed a cake for my sons birthday and the staff here was very friendly and gave me great personalized service. Can't wait for the next occasion to buy another cake from here.
S
Stephen white
Google
a year ago
4.0
I'm a happy customer. Taste was great.
L
Lynne Mayers-Thomas
Google
3 weeks ago
5.0
This is my first experience. Someone dear to me loves this place and I was going to be in the area. If the goodies are anything near to what you smell when you open the door then I have a real treat coming after dinner. I had to force myself to leave as everything looked delicious.
V
Vanessa Rodriguez
Google
3 weeks ago
5.0
Lovely atmosphere. Find traditional aspects. Follows CDC guidelines for covid 19. Server was nice and curtis. The hot chocolate was so on point and the best on a cold day like today. The cookies and cake AMAZING!
M
Martha Bernard
Google
5 months ago
5.0
This is the only place I get all my cakes from. The best in Nwe York city. The works are all nice and courteous. Have nothing negative to say.
D
Derrick Weaver
Google
5 months ago
5.0
It was brief and beautiful. Employees are extremely cautious and pleasant,, attentive and welcoming. I'll recommend to any and everyone. My favorite place.
U
Uroosa Ijaz
Google
6 months ago
5.0
I ordered a red velvet cake for my nephew's graduation celebration. First off, the quality of the cake itself warrants 5/5 stars. It was rich and the cream cheese frosting was spot on. But on top of that, the staff took the time to decorate the cake for the occasion at no additional cost. They were extremely receptive, kind, and willing to help. I would highly recommend
A
Alexander George
Google
6 months ago
3.0
Sadly, the red velvet cake missed the mark with the icing. You don't get that cream cheese icing that really gives this cake the pop it deserves, it tastes completely like confections sugar. However the texture of the cake is amazing moist and rich and that's very important as well. Great customer service though.
D
DCCupcake Critic
Zomato
Oct 22, 2012
4.5
I remember the first time I visited Make My Cake...it was heavenly.
J
Johnna Knows Good Food
Zomato
Mar 22, 2011
0.0
Sweets in the City. If you’re looking for love in New York you turn to Sex and the City, if you’re looking for sweets Make My Cake is where you go. All the cupcakes you can eat!! We love the red velvet cupcakes with the pecan topped icing. The cheesecake is worth a commute uptown to Harlem and the clear seating decor makes it even more fun for sweet
J
Jessie Oleson
Zomato
Dec 21, 2008
0.0
What follows here is a love story between Cakespy and Make My Cake . We met this bakery years ago, at its old location, near the 2 and 3 train entrance on 110th Street. The location was unlikely, near a fried chicken joint, correctional facility and a den
