Fat Witch Bakery

We got three small brownies: citrus had a great flavour, and Macha one had a full matcha flavour which I loved (considering some bakeries have just a hint of macha flavour). Unfortunately, their texture was not fudge or brownie-ish. It is more like a dense cakey texture. I wasn't much fan of a ginger one even though I usually love ginger flavour. Great place to visit and explore, but don't hold your expectations high up there.

I ordered a tin of assorted brownies from Fat Witch Bakery for my sister’s birthday, who is a self-proclaimed brownie connoisseur, and it was perfect! The ordering process was a piece of cake. I placed my order online, and it was processed the same day. The brownies were shipped the next day and arrived via USPS Priority Mail within the same week. Super impressive! The packaging was simply adorable! Fat Witch Bakery really knows how to charm with their branding. It's everywhere – from the shipping box to the tin, and even on each individually wrapped brownie. And the gift card? Just the cherry on top! Each brownie was individually wrapped and labeled with its flavor, making it an exciting treasure hunt for the tastebuds. My sister couldn't stop raving about how fresh and fudgy each brownie was. Plus, the option to freeze them or pop them in the fridge for later was a big hit. And the fun doesn't stop there. The tin, proudly boasting 'FAT WITCH' on the outside, is set to make a comeback as a quirky gift box for one of her friends. While I've never set foot in the store, this online experience has made me a fan. I'm definitely coming back for more, and I'd recommend Fat Witch Bakery in a heartbeat to anyone looking for a delightful and unique gift for their brownie-loving friends.

Simple and to the point, they even had samples. They are smooth but with a nice thickness in the bite and the edges have crunch, perfect texture. Sweeter than their competitor for the best brownie in town (mah ze dahr) which is a matter of preference. The texture here wins. There are also many kinds, I didn't notice the difference between salty and regular, but the berry one adds sourness that upgrades it even more if you like that genre.

A great snack-ish dessert as you’re exiting the Chelsea Market. When we planned to visit the Chelsea Market, my girlfriend was recommended to check out this brownie shop and it didn’t disappoint. A lot of the shops in Chelsea Market tend to be quite pricey, but thankfully Fat Witch were on the lower side when it came to prices around $5-6 for a moderate sized brownie. We grabbed the Blonde Witch and a regular chocolate brownie. The blonde witch was a perfect subtle flavouring that wasn’t too over-bearingly sweet which my girlfriend really liked. The chocolate was your classic chocolate brownie, not much to write home about. One thing I didn’t like, was that I was expecting…more. I really wanted this to be a gobsmackingly good brownie that would be incredibly soft but rather it was somewhat dry. Might just be the time of day we purchased ours. Overall, if you’re looking for a nice little dessert to fill you sweet tooth or to keep the kids happy, look towards Fat Witch Bakery in the Chelsea Market.